« June 2009 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30
You are not logged in. Log in
Entries by Topic
All topics  «
Skwigg Blog
Tuesday, 9 June 2009
What if I can't diet or exercise?

In the name of posting some text and moving the gross picture of the Luther burgers further down the page, here is a random question from my e-mails this week.

Q: I've tried so many different diets and I can't exercise due to ankle problems. I feel like I'm running out of options. Any advice on what I should do?

A: This is going to sound snarky, and I don't mean to sound snarky at all. I say this with nothing but humor and affection - what's wrong with the rest of your body? If you're talking one ankle (or two ankles) and the rest of your body is fine, you can still exercise. If weight-bearing cardio is out, you can bike or swim. If biking and swimming are out, you can lift weights. If you don't have weights, you can do bodyweight exercises. If mentally, you just can't stand the thought of setting foot in a gym, or sweating, or lifting things, you can do yoga or Pilates at home.

There's always a way to increase your activity just a little bit. It doesn't have to be major. It can be a part of your day- a few leg lifts while you're talking on the phone, some resistance band exercises while watching television, a stretch before bed. Moving even a teeny tiny bit makes you feel better about yourself, which leads to a more positive outlook, better food decisions, and eventual results. It's not a matter of, "I need to burn 500 calories or else I won't bother." You can always do something to improve your situation.

Diets don't work at all, so I don't recommend those. If you go "on" something, you're guaranteed to go "off" or it at some point. Your daily habits should be enjoyable and support your goals. Don't deny yourself anything. Include your some of your favorite foods and routines so you can look forward to your meals. Keep it flexible and fun. It's mainly a matter of learning balance and portion control. It's not a horrible proposition where you're going to starve and never eat carbs and never go to restaurants. I really liked the book Naturally Thin by Bethenny Frankel as a guide to knocking off the dieting and incorporating your favorite foods. Here are a couple of blog entries where I reviewed it: Naturally Thin and Naturally Thin for the Non-Elf.

Basically, what I'm saying is baby steps. You don't have to go on a diet, or take up a grueling exercise program. You just have to move in the direction of your dreams. If you dream of being lean, healthy, and happy, do things that make you feel that way. All of the struggle, uncertainty and pain comes from doing things that are at odds with what your heart wants. If you want to be fit, healthy, and balanced, pigging out on junk food (or not eating at all) is at odds with your vision and will make you feel horrible. If your ankles hurt, deciding to become a runner will create massive mental and physical conflict and make you feel horrible. Avoid things that make you feel horrible and do things that bring you joy.

Health and fitness is a state of mind more than anything else. Change your mind and you change your body. I have this quote stuck on my desk. "You speak your world into existence. What did you say to yourself today?"


Posted by skwigg at 8:56 AM CDT

Tuesday, 9 June 2009 - 9:25 AM CDT

Name: "angelina "
Home Page: http://thedestinywithin.blogspot.com/

 

You make some fantasic points about execuses people think up to avoid exercise.  My motto is "just move"  and "keep it moving"  

Tuesday, 9 June 2009 - 11:28 AM CDT

Name: "Cheree"
Home Page: http://dolphyngyrl.blogspot.com

Really? "Can't" excercise? Hell, even I wouldn't try to pass off that excuse!

My wife spent a few semesters in the Adaptive PE program at the local junior college (she has a spinal fusion and can't do certain things). The classes there had people with a wide range of disabilities, including one or two who had extremely limited mobility. But they still showed up for class each day and did everything they were capable of doing. 

 If you think you have a physical limitation, look locally for adaptive programs. Our area has a program not just at our junior college, but we have a local agency that provides sports and recreation activities for those who don't have full mobility. Most of the time, the programs are even free or low cost. 

 And if you still think you "can't", get your hands on a copy of Murderball (link's a video). 

 Also, remember that you don't have to stick to a "diet". The best thing you can do is simple:

 Move more. Eat less. 

The best part is that anyone can do that. 

Tuesday, 9 June 2009 - 12:55 PM CDT

Name: "Kelley Moore"
Home Page: http://www.getfitwithkelley.blogspot.com

Unfortunately I think this type of thinking (I fail at diets, I can't exercise because of xyz) is a lot more common than we probably want to acknowledge. I see or hear some version of it every day. I'd rather hear someone flat out say they are not ready to implement what they are learning rather than use something like this as an excuse. But my heart really goes out to someone who actually believes this and feels trapped. It seems we're still mired down by the dieting mentality, which keeps people feeling defeated and so many people seem paralyzed by the exercise thing. You nailed the "all or nothing" mentality very well when you basically said don't throw in the towel if you can't create a 500 calorie deficit today. From a broad perspective I can't understand how we spend years doing damage to our bodies, have a wealth of knowledge at our fingertips, then think there must be some sort of magic carpet ride from the state I'm in today to looking and feeling like the latest skinny movie star. It's like some sort of abyss and I can't quite figure it out. I'd like to see people tune in to exactly who they are right now, then figure out what their heart wants as you described so well, then use every resource available to break out of the defeated mode and starting making positive changes.

Tuesday, 9 June 2009 - 1:15 PM CDT

Name: "Cynthia"
Home Page: http://www.garbagethatgoo.com

Good post! The deal about exercise is so true! I have ankle problems, foot problems (plantar fasciitis), a bad right knee, chronic tendinitis in my arms and a currently quite flared up right arm. Shoulder issues as well. And I still manage to exercise. I can't do everything... but I do what I can.

Water workouts are really excellent for folks with problems and past injuries!  

Tuesday, 9 June 2009 - 3:30 PM CDT

Name: "Marsha"

Wow, "problems with ankles" is pretty nonspecific - I don't know how anyone can advise as to what this person can or cannot do.  I suspect that a physical therapist or sports medicine doctor could advise him or her, however. 

That said, I have no clue who's the best source of information on healthy eating, esp. if the goal is weight loss (which is implied by the question).  Doctors are clueless; nutritionists just follow the food pyramid; most everyone else is just trying to sell their product.  JMO.

Tuesday, 9 June 2009 - 5:31 PM CDT

Name: "julie O."

Thank you thank you thank you - for moving the picture down and for your offerings here.  Very sane.  After my last rather gloomy post, someone responded with something about serotonin, and I thought, oops, that's me - too much low carb stuff did me in.  I added in some crackers from time to time and feel terrific.  Sometimes there's just a stumbling bock to exercise, even a mental one, like don't have enough mental energy to exercise, which needs a boost.  just back from gym and my favorite cross trainer. 

Tuesday, 9 June 2009 - 6:07 PM CDT

Name: "Amber"

Lord Renee!  When are you going to write a book?!?!

Wednesday, 10 June 2009 - 7:19 AM CDT

Name: "nic"

i just enrolled in the PN lean eating program. one of the best things i far done so far, well apart from reading your blog! it's early days still and the PN team are breaking it all down into tiny little steps every day. the basic workout ethos theme though has already emerged. it's basically join a gym or retrofit your living space into one! or forget about getting results from the program. i recently bought a TRX and thought this was all i would need. was i being overly naiive? as much as i hate it , i can feel the resistance towards heavy weight lifting workouts building strongly. i know it's completely irrational, but from my past 10 years experience of working out i know i always burn out on these types of workouts pretty soon and i've never been able to sustain them in the long term. i despise gyms and prefer to bike or run outdoors as much as possible. the other thing i like is vinyasa/power yoga. haven't tried the TRX yet, but the possiblity of working out outdoors anywhere is what bought me in. am i fooling myself? do i need to overcome my dislike of gyms and home gym equipment in order to realise my goal of a six-pack? i hope not. you've also proven otherwise. do i listen to my heart or jb?

Wednesday, 10 June 2009 - 8:32 AM CDT

Name: "betty"

just wondering...any more spots in the PN coaching program?

Wednesday, 10 June 2009 - 8:50 AM CDT

Name: skwigg
Home Page: http://skwigg.tripod.com

nic - Definitely, express these concerns to your coaching group and let them answer this question.

My advice is that if you're in the coaching program, listen to JB! You can listen to your heart later. ;-) It would be like hiring an elite strength and conditioning coach (which you've done) and then saying, "But I'm not going to lift weights or come to the gym."

The TRX is a killer workout. JB uses it and writes programs around it. It's not a matter of one piece of equipment being better than another. All that matters is whether you're going to commit to or resist your coaching. You'll get better and faster results if you commit than if you start second guessing and changing things. 

You can always be a tree-swinging free spirit AFTER you have the six pack! :-D

Often the fastest way to your fitness goals is to get out of your own way and let a professional take over. That works. Winging it on your own and making it up as you go may or may not work, because everything you do on your own will be clouded by what you LIKE, not necessarily what delivers.

I went to the gym and did exactly what my trainer told me to do 3-5 times per week for years. It wasn't always fun, I didn't always enjoy the process, but I loooooved the results. I have nothing but gratitude and fond memories of all the heavy crap I was forced to lift and all the times I nearly threw up my lungs. That experience of being coached and pushed way outside of my comfort zone built so much character and determination! It helped me achieve my fitness goals quickly and maintain them without any doubts. 

Achieving your dream abs is not a matter of TRX vs weights, or indoors vs outdoors. The biggest factor is mental. It's whether you're committed to the process, whether you're coachable. If you're not and you just want to go outside and play, there's nothing wrong with that but you can't expect the same results.

Also, final point in this big ramble - abs are all about nutrition, and you're definitely in the right place for that!

Wednesday, 10 June 2009 - 9:07 AM CDT

Name: "nic"

thanks skwigg! yes, i agree, sometimes it's better to receive some butt-kicking!

Wednesday, 10 June 2009 - 9:22 AM CDT

Name: "nic"

@betty: looks like pn LE is full, as always, but there's always the waiting list. next starting date jan 2009, just in time for new year's resolutions. i was so eager to not miss my opportunity this time round that first i wrote an angry email when they didn't open regristration on time, and then anxiously awaited the email. when the email with the registration link arrived, i madly clicked the first link in sight and promptly registered for the male's program *blush* thankfully that was sorted out ....

 

i just went over to the forum and my prayer's have been answered. overnight a thread emerged with bodyweight substitutions for the exercises. if i combine the suggestions with the TRX, i'm probably good to go until the gym situation is sorted out . it's raining hard outside anyway, not much fun going outdoors in that weather.

Wednesday, 10 June 2009 - 11:52 AM CDT

Name: "brenda"

A few months ago I was at the gym, thinking I didn't want to be there, didn't feel like it, etc.  In fact, I almost gave myself a mental health day from working out as scheduled/needed.  Anyway, I look over and see a woman strapped into a wheelchair with two other women holding her arms onto a cybex machine and helping her do rows. 

At that moment I KNEW I could never have a valid excuse to just "not feel like it."

Wednesday, 10 June 2009 - 1:26 PM CDT

Name: "RG"

it does sound snarky to me, and ultimately giving advice (even to people who ask) is hard.  It's hard because the non-snarky answer is "don't change anything, keep doing what you're doing, it'll all work out".  If that worked, they wouldn't be coming to you for advice.  But that's what people expect to hear, in my experience.  I got yelled at recently for telling someone who was about-to-puke that they may need to lower the intensity for a bit or stop earlier; the yeller was another person who insisted that the right answer was that the puker was dehydrated.  Umm, okay, that's a different problem that might be happening, but that's not my experience.

I'm frustrated with that process, where I've been exercising a long time and I know a thing or two, and people ask.  And it's hard to tell whether they want to hear 'there, there, you did the best you could" or they want an actual solution to their problems.  And often it feels like "the road is right here, if you want it" but I know that we all have to find our own road, there are lots of roads, and sometimes the way to get on the road is to go backwards for a while.  Learn not to diet by dieting.

 And ultimately, we all have limitations to our final abilities.  I don't think we can all achieve whatever we want; I've tested enough of my limits to understand that.  So maybe life handed you a limited fitness ability, but maybe it made up for it somewhere else.  Especially with injuries, which are often life's way of saying "you're trying too hard, back off".

Wednesday, 10 June 2009 - 2:31 PM CDT

Name: "Kemccar"

I loved this post.  I am in the LE coaching program too.  The LE coaches don't stand for any of these excuses - for example if you post that you haven't been able to do the exercises because of say a pulled calf muscle, then the coaches shoot back "ok as to the legs, but you have been doing the upper body work, right??  right???").  

I avoid the gym at all costs and have been using my TRX to do some approximation of some of the exercises that I don't otherwise have the equipment for.  (But I also have over many years retrofitted my spare room into a gym with sets of dumbbells up to 25lbs, barbell, chinup bar, all sorts of bands, yoga ball, kettle bell (new addition - going to a separate trainer for lessons on that one!)).

The TRX has been great on assisted pull ups and chin ups and modified neutral position pull ups.  I am trying to do what I can to follow the program exactly with what I have and so far it seems to be working. 

My husband came into the room when I was doing chin ups using the TRX (feet in the TRX, hands on the bar, grunting - quite a spectacle) and said it occurred to him that I'd do very well in prison.   

View Latest Entries