« February 2008 »
S M T W T F S
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29
You are not logged in. Log in
Entries by Topic
All topics  «
Skwigg Blog
Sunday, 24 February 2008
Does Clutter Make You Fat?

Organizational expert Peter Walsh has a new book called Does This Clutter Make My Butt Look Fat? Somebody should have intervened on that title. However, the man does have a point. I've seen hundreds of before and after pictures of 12 week Body for Life challengers. Call me nosy, crazy, or obsessive compulsive, but I'm always fascinated with what's behind the person in the photo. I've seen many sad, slouchy before photos where it looks like a bomb has gone off behind the person, clothes, toys, dishes, boxes, books, and random junk strewn everywhere. However, I've never seen a single lean, fit, radiant after photo with a train wreck in the background.

 

So what changes during that 12 week period? Maybe people just die of mortification, wise up, and photograph themselves against a blank wall for the after photos. Or perhaps as they become lean, fit, organized, and confident, those new feelings carry over into their life and their surroundings.

 

Peter Walsh says, "Consider for a moment that where you live, what you own, how you interact with others, what you eat, and how you spend your time are all intimately linked. You can't change one piece without affecting all the others. Declutter your mind, declutter your home, declutter your relationship to food."  

What does this mean for you? Well if you're a neat freak with single digit body fat, a pristine home gym set-up, and a freezer full of healthy color-coded Tupperware meals, it means nothing. You get it already. But if you're a pack rat with a weight problem, you must ask yourself these questions: Are the dishes in the sink, the cluttered counter tops, the cupboards full of junk food, the clothes hanging on the treadmill, and the complete lack of floor space, helping or hurting your fitness efforts? Do your surroundings inspire you to make positive, healthy choices, to be your best self, or do they drag you back down? Can you create a new life in the same space that caused you to gain the weight?  

Things that make you go, hmmmm...  

To learn more about losing weight by getting organized (it's definitely not a "diet" book) check out, Does This Clutter Make My Butt Look Fat? 

 

 

It's been my experience that when the house is a disaster (moving, kitchen remodeling, painting, closet cleaning, etc.) I want easy and I want OUT, and that tends to involve a trip to the nearest fast food restaurant. I'm not going to grill chicken or make a salad or do a workout when the house makes me shudder. Stacks of boxes and piles of junk put me in a to-hell-with-it kind of hopeless mood.  

What about you? Have you seen a weight/clutter connection? Do you have more success following a fitness program when you're organized? Do you gain weight when everything around you is in disarray?


Posted by skwigg at 10:31 AM CST

Sunday, 24 February 2008 - 12:27 PM CST

Name: "Naomi"

I absolutely agree!

 How the heck can I work up the motivation to fix my broccoli-zucchini-teriyaki meatball stir-fry if I don't even have a clear space to cut up my vegetables, or if all my necessary pots and spoons need washing? Having a clean kitchen before I go to bed is a top priority.

 The correlation to the messiness of the rest of the house isn't quite as strong, but it's still there. It's hard to focus when you know there's an avalanche of dirty laundry waiting for you in the back room.

 Yeah, I'd have to say that over the past five years, the cleanliness of my house has improved along with my physical fitness. One factor is that I now have the energy for house-cleaning, along with the strength to move a couch or refrigerator if I need to.

Sunday, 24 February 2008 - 12:55 PM CST

Name: "Glynis"
Home Page: http://glynisp.multiply.com

Interesting... but I think the jury is out.  Personally,  I think that the people just cleaned up the background for their after pictures.  Alot of them are even done by a professional or if not a pro, a friend who is just really good with cameras.  The first pictures are usually done a bit more quickly because the person feels out of shape & unenthused. 

I homeschool (and have for16 years), so clutter is part of our life.  We always have school books, books in general and paper-stuff on flat surfaces everywhere that gets picked up every few days, only to show back up again. .  My kids are all healthy, fit & athletic.  We manage to keep the kitchen neat, so maybe that's a factor in making healthy meals.  We just don't do fast food very often, and when we do it is healthy chinese, salads & stuff.  

Sunday, 24 February 2008 - 12:57 PM CST

Name: "Glynis"
Home Page: http://glynisp.multiply.com

I have to add a P.S. to this... about if it is easier to follow a fitness program when you're organized... Clutter doesn't necessarily mean disorganization.  Clutter can be organized stuff that you just can't figure out where to put OR you want to access quickly.  

Sunday, 24 February 2008 - 1:38 PM CST

Name: "Sarah"
Home Page: http://yalooblue.blogspot.com

Absolutely. I'm sort of a neat freak anyway, but I find that my whole life is organized if my "stuff" is in it's places.

Oh Renee. I don't know if your dogs are of the "herding" nature, but we have a Welsh Corgie and they need jobs to be happy. So, our little Vinnie (his name) has decided that "helping" with my boyfriend (the ice machine) is his job. On the hour he bouces up the stairs with my mom and sit while she fills the ice and watches to make sure it's being done correctly. It's hilarious.

 

Sunday, 24 February 2008 - 3:52 PM CST

Name: "Cindy"
Home Page: http://www.kiniwoman.com/

I really agree with the clutter/weight relationship.

When things look like a train wreck or the aftermath of a natural disaster, I tend to think 'what the h***! I don't care!' and get all discouraged, and like you want OUT and FAST and EASY. It sucks the life right out of you.

I also do think that there can be "organized clutter" but that really isn't what we are talking about, right? 

Sunday, 24 February 2008 - 5:42 PM CST

Name: "Dr. Ding"
Home Page: http://www.askdrding.com

I most definitely hve an easier time staying in a healthy eat/move/work groove when I'm organized and at Clutter Zero.

That said, I do like a certain amount of clutter in my life when it comes to my piles of books and magazines, my beading and knitting projects, and my garden.  It's just lots more fun for me to "play" in a certain amount of mess... it's almost as fun as leaves and mud puddles!  But, when it comes to serious stuff like my health and my work, I like the neatness. 

Sunday, 24 February 2008 - 8:05 PM CST

Name: "RDO"

That's odd. I was just thinking that you never see fit healthy people on "How Clean is Your House?"

Monday, 25 February 2008 - 1:07 PM CST

Name: "DeDe"

Fascinating correlation!  I totally agree, but then I'm an OCD-ridden ninny anyway.

You know, Suze Orman also says the first step in cleaning up one's finances is to clean up one's house.  She definitely believe there's a connection between clutter in the home and clutter in the pocketbook.

Monday, 25 February 2008 - 7:54 PM CST

Name: "Judy"

Funny you should mention this.....I lost 4.5 pounds in January and  since the first week or so of Feb. I have had no kitchen.   We are remodeling and I have no floor (well, concrete), cabinets, counter tops, water or appliances.  I am also feeling puffy, eating poorly and scared to weigh. 

Tuesday, 26 February 2008 - 10:56 AM CST

Name: "Dara Chadwick"
Home Page: http://darachadwick.typepad.com

Hmmm, indeed! I haven't read the book, but I will say I was supremely organized about shopping, meals and food during my year with Shape. But something you wrote really resonated with me -- the line about when the house is a mess, you want easy. We've recently moved back into our house after a major construction project and we're doing much of the finish work ourselves, which, of course, means it's slow going and generally a mess around here. I have to say, we've been slipping back into a bad take-out habit and now I'm wondering if there's a correlation between my semi torn-apart kitchen and dining room and my lack of desire to cook.

All the more reason to finish this crazy-making project!

Tuesday, 26 February 2008 - 9:31 PM CST

Name: "Sandra"

OK, my first reaction was to laugh so hard about the title...super funny.  I can see how there could be a correlation, but I'm not so sure if we can make generalizations. I must admit that our house tends to be a wreck most of the time, but part of it is being busy with work, trecking the kids to their classes, and taking time for myself at the gym.  If I have to choose between going to the gym early in the morning or tidying up and doing another load of laundry, I get my workout in!  If I spent all my time tidying and sorting clutter (toys, papers, etc), I'd get fatter because I wouldnt make it to the gym and walk or cycle to work. Hmmmm....

Wednesday, 27 February 2008 - 5:03 AM CST

Name: "Louise"

I would have to say this holds some truth for me - but not from a practicality point where the mess physically gets in the way of healthy cooking /exercising - but I feel more on top of things, more able to do things, happier with myself when I've bothered to tidy up my house and things look nice and feel comfortable. And that helps me make sure I bother to do the healthy things and feel good about that too!

Wednesday, 27 February 2008 - 9:14 AM CST

Name: "maya"
Home Page: http://springtreeroad.typepad.com

I'm having a really difficult time lately. I gained back 25 pounds I had lost and have not been able to find the motivation to begin again. I stay home with my 2 year old and the place is, honestly, a wreck. We live in a tiny apartment and when I look around and see stuff piled up or on the floor, I know it's because none of those things has a place to go. You know "a place for everything and everything in its place"? We don't have that right now.

The good news is we're moving in two months and plan to get a house, which means we'll have more room. But to answer your question - he's right. When I go into the kitchen and see that there's no rooms on the already tiny countertops, well, the last thing I want to do is spend an hour making salads for lunches. I want to order in Thai.

Also, after 1.5 years of exercising (though now that I'm reading The Rules of Lifting for Women, I realize the reason I wasn't getting results), I quit the gym and haven't been exercising at home. So maybe for me it's not a matter of doing the exercising and then magically cleaning up my house. Maybe I need to clean the house first and the diet/exercise will follow more easily. Because I feel like I've tried everything else. 

Wednesday, 27 February 2008 - 1:57 PM CST

Name: "M A"

OMG.  Maybe THAT is my problem! When I worked full-time and attended college full-time, a disorganized home, clutter, laundry piling up, etc., drove me nuts and made it hard for me to concentrate on my studies.  I had to get things in some sort of order, or it cluttered my mind.  Now I'm working lots of hours and have a long commute, so the house, countertops, etc., are equally making me crazy.  I took a few days off to clean just so I could clear my head.

I've not been doing as well with workouts and eating, and I'll bet this is why!!  I'll have to work on that.  Thanks for opening my eyes!

Thursday, 28 February 2008 - 1:12 PM CST

Name: "Cynthia"
Home Page: http://www.garbagethatgoo.com

Funny, I just finished reading this book and am returning it to the library today!

There *may* be a connection between clutter and bodyfat, but I'm not entirely convinced. I certainly don't think the BFL photos are evidence, I just think people cleaned their act up better for their after photos.

My mother was, essentially, a clutter queen. I'm talking serious clutter as a monkey on her back. Yet, she lost her excess weight through WW and walking and pretty well kept it off the rest of her life, though she NEVER solved her clutter issue.

Me, I'm overweight, my kitchen is pretty much UNcluttered and I keep it that way, so I can eat regularly and healthy without fuss. But the dining room table gets cluttered and portions of the house get cluttered. It's an ongoing battle for me. I do think that the better I feel and as the weight comes off, I will cope with my clutter a little better. It's hard to keep up with a foot injury and the doctor telling me I should be off my feet!

But I do regularly try to go through stuff and toss things I don't need out or give them away.  Maybe I am just transitional.

I do think less clutter is a happier state of affairs for me. And maybe when you don't have the stress of the clutter and mess on you, it is easier to lose weight, not to mention to find places to exercise at home.

Friday, 29 February 2008 - 9:39 AM CST

Name: "Success Warrior"
Home Page: http://successwarrior.typepad.com/chronicles

For me, it works the other way.  The more I take care of my health, the more I take care of other things in my life, including clutter.

Having said that, I still believe that your environment plays a big roll in achieving your goals.  My wife and I have set fitness as our primary goal until June.  To accomplish this, we have rearranged our house.

Our living room is now a big open space where we can both do cardio at the same time and I can teach martial arts.  The room formerly known as the office is now the weight room with my bench and free weights.  The computer desk has been set in a corner in the living room where it doesn't interfere with the cardio.

Our house isn't set up to be very friendly as far as social settings (unless you want to come over for a workout ) but being social isn't our goal.  The more factors you change that support your goal, the more likely you are to succeed.

Friday, 29 February 2008 - 10:24 AM CST

Name: "janet"

this is very true. I am currently reading "Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind" and it talks about the same sort of thing. How you must free your living space in order to free up your mind, etc. There is definately a link. Although, I am kind of skeptical since I am thin but really super messy? I don't work out as much as I should though, nor do I have a very "calm" mind... So I think it's maybe less to do about weight but more a state-of-mind...

Thursday, 6 March 2008 - 9:40 PM CST

Name: "Julie"

"How you do anything is how you do everything."

 For anyone wondering about clutter, flylady.com.   Great resource.

I took the kitchen that last ten percent toward clarity yesterday, but really it was more like 40% in the end for what it yielded - the few more things put away, the moving of the butcher block 2 feet, the placement of those pans, and wow, we're in business again.  Stocked kitchen with gourmet nutriton food list and am happy camper.   Why is chicken so expensive in Virginia?

 

-Julie 

View Latest Entries