« December 2007 »
S M T W T F S
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31
You are not logged in. Log in
Entries by Topic
All topics  «
Skwigg Blog
Monday, 24 December 2007
The New Rules of Lifting for Women

You know how appalled I am when great programs get dumbed down and painted pink for the little ladies. You may recall how I railed against Pamela Peeke's Body for Life for Women. It was a prime example of telling women what they want to hear (and what sells) instead of what actually works. Her underlying message was - there there dear, if you don't have the body you want, blame your age, blame your gender, blame your hormones, lift your little weights, eat your domino-sized portions, and learn to accept your "menopot." Gah!!

So, when I heard that Alwyn Cosgrove and company were coming out with a "women's" version of The New Rules of Lifting, I nearly seized. Once I quit hyperventilating, I e-mailed Alwyn something along the lines of, oh god, what have you done to it? Rather than trying to talk me down, he just sent me a copy. I'm happy to report that, if anything, he made it harder than a lot of men's programs. The subtitle is Lift Like a Man, Look Like a Goddess, and it includes chapters like Step Away from the Treadmill, A Woman's Place is In the Weight Room, and Our Meal Plans Can Beat Up Their Meal Plans.

In other words, they got it totally right! The emphasis is on food, muscle, and metabolism. Alwyn's workouts are brilliant and diabolical as usual. Lou Schuler is a riot. His "Yes, You" chapter about self-imposed roadblocks and limitations made me laugh out loud. Cassandra Forsythe's meal plans are all about raising your metabolism, not crushing it. She starts the food plan at maintenance levels and explains the pitfalls of drastic calorie slashing. If you want a lean body and a fast metabolism, you can't achieve it through a quick-fix starvation diet.

It includes six months of total body workouts. They're divided into seven stages, including an optional strength-focused stage to condition you for doing full chin-ups, and a "final cut" phase for blasting the last bit of body fat. There are photos and descriptions of each exercise, home gym alternatives, recipes, fast food options, sample full-day meal plans, and worksheets for tracking progress.

What are these "new rules" you ask? Well there are over 20 of them, but allow me to share a couple of my favorites. The purpose of lifting weights is to build muscle. THANK YOU!! The purpose is not to tone, tighten, sculpt, lengthen, firm, spot reduce, de-jiggle, banish trouble spots, or any of the other idiotic euphemisms that women's publications normally use to trick women into lifting; the purpose of lifting weights is to build muscle (duh!). Another one of my very favorites is Calorie restriction is the worst idea ever. Clearly, I'm all over that one. Back in my diet ninny years, I was a hungry flabby mess. As long as I dieted, I sagged. Now that I eat often and eat well, I'm lean and strong. Funny how that works! Another of my favorite rules - No workout will make you taller. It addresses the women who are desperately trying to "lengthen" themselves in pilates class or by following a supermodel's stay-slim toning program. It's followed by an explanation of muscle physiology that ought to dispel any fears about accidentally getting hyoooge. Loved the example (complete with measurements) of what happens to a woman who gains 9 pounds of lean mass.

Times are definitely changing in the world of strength training and fat loss. If you're still back in the 80's and 90's with your low-fat, low-calorie diet, body part splits, isolation exercises, and monotonous steady-state cardio, you really need to read this book. It will bring you up to speed on the latest research and dramatically improve your results.

The New Rules of Lifting for Women is a great read for women who lift weights, or men who are trying to coax a wife or girlfriend into the weight room. It doesn't assume that women are weaker-willed and less competent than the average guy. In fact, I think it assumes that we're smarter and have a higher pain tolerance. :-D


Posted by skwigg at 1:22 PM CST

Monday, 24 December 2007 - 10:18 PM CST

Name: "anonymous"

Well I'm glad it's another book that's going in the right direction! But I really have to stop myself and wonder what's left that the other hero's haven't already told us.  Hope you're having a wonderful holiday season!

Wednesday, 26 December 2007 - 10:00 AM CST

Name: "maya"

i'm thinking of getting this book now that i've read your review - even though i've sworn off all "diet" books.

i'm wondering if you've read eat to live by dr. joel fuhrman and what you think of that?

Wednesday, 26 December 2007 - 11:36 AM CST

Name: skwigg

No worries, New Rules is definitely not a diet book. It's a strength training manual with a couple of sports nutrition chapters. Without the advice on eating to fuel workouts, plenty of women would attempt these killer routines while consuming 1400 calories per day of lettuce and rice cakes. And that would be really counterproductive

I'd never heard of Eat to Live. I just glanced at the Amazon description and they totally lost me at "Losing 20 pounds in two to three weeks is just the beginning." Now THAT sounds like a diet book! But, if it emphasizes nutrient-dense whole foods over the standard American diet, it can't be too terrible. Anything is an improvement over McMuffins, Whoppers and Ho-Hos.

Thursday, 27 December 2007 - 10:44 AM CST

Name: "yogini"

I agree with all that you said, with the exception of the "new rules" that no workout will make you taller.  I am living proof that a consistent yoga practice (in my case, Bikram yoga) will lenghten your spine. I "grew" 3/4" in 16 months, documented by my physician.  My fitness routine (weights/cardio) remained the same...the only thing I changed was that I added Bikram yoga.  And, I am not an anomaly, as I know at least 4 other women at the studios I attend who have also grown taller through a regular, kick-ass practice of Bikram yoga.  Namaste.

Thursday, 27 December 2007 - 4:20 PM CST

Name: "Spirophita"
Home Page: http://www.blogrhetorica.blogspot.com

I am SO buying this book. What a great book to debunk all those myths. If I have one more woman ask me why I would lift weights when cardio makes you slim, I will literally hit her over the head with this book.

Friday, 28 December 2007 - 11:03 AM CST

Name: "maya"

it's a vegan diet, though you don't have to follow it to the T. he advocates tons of fruit, vegetables, beans, nuts. he says it helps you lose weight naturally and that you'll come to your ideal weight this way. he is also about cancer prevention and living a long life. it's hard to follow (for me, anyway), but if you can do it i think it's a wonderful way to eat.

Friday, 28 December 2007 - 12:56 PM CST

Name: "Heidi Swift"
Home Page: http://everydayathleteblog.com/

Skwigg!  

Great review... and I am equally relieved to hear the Cosgrove got it right. (I am similarly repelled by the dumbing-down of weight-training for women and frequently get worked up into a veritable LATHER when the topic comes up!)

Consider the book on order. 

Friday, 28 December 2007 - 2:53 PM CST

Name: "Angike"
Home Page: http://www.womensdietandfitness.com

I have been waiting for this book to come out. I loved The New Rules of Lifting and was thinking of going back to it, until I saw this being advertised! I am so ready to kick some serious butt, as I know these workouts will do to me! ;)

Saturday, 29 December 2007 - 5:05 PM CST

Name: "Clara"

You know I just saw this at the bookstore and walked away thinking it was another dumbed down workout for women. Thanks to the review, I'll be grabbing it tomorrow. I work in a gym and am always looking for good material to help my female members understand that the free weight area is your friend. 

 

Good deal. Thanks, and hope you have a happy new year! 

Saturday, 29 December 2007 - 9:10 PM CST

Name: "Glynis"
Home Page: http://glynisp.multiply.com

So, how do the workouts compare to those in Afterburn and Turbulence Training?  Did you ever get Making the Cut?  If so, how do things compare to the variety in that?  I *need* variety.  I can't cope with the same six or seven exercises done over and over.

Sunday, 30 December 2007 - 12:31 AM CST

Name: "skwigg"

I think there's plenty of variety in all of them, plenty of whacked out exercises I've never seen before in all of them, and enough periodization that you never repeat a workout more than a couple of times before moving on to something new and different.

Jillian is probably still tops in the entertainment/variety department, but I'm more interested in results than in being entertained. I like a strong foundation of squats, deadlifts, presses and rows with some insanity on top. New Rules delivers that.

Making the Cut is more of a fast circuit / boot camp / keep your heart rate up / lose the last 5 pounds program. New Rules is about lifting heavy to build muscle. No frills.

Monday, 31 December 2007 - 2:40 PM CST

Name: "Glynis"
Home Page: http://glynisp.multiply.com

It sounds interesting.  I'm one of those women who can lift a soup can and build muscle. Must be my Lithuanian peasant stock ancestry - I have to change things up, heavy one day, lighter the next, etc, or I do get bulky (no matter who says women can't). My linebacker thighs don't need much to keep them that way, so I loved the variety of crazy circuits and plyometerics.  I might buy The New Rules as a New Year's gift to myself and then just incorporate it for my heavier days.

Sunday, 6 January 2008 - 12:33 PM CST

Name: "Ladysmom"

Swigg,

I had been looking for Alywyn's New Rules of Lifting at my local Barnes & Noble.  Couldn't find it (gee,what a surprise) there, so I bought Lori Incledon's Strength Training for Women instead, which seems decent so far.  I have ordered New Rules for Women now that I know it's out there -- thanks for the heads up!  Looking forward to a Lift-o-Rama.  My goal is to be able to do an unassisted pull up by my birthday (end of February), so I am especially eager to see his workouts for building up to pull ups.  Happy New Year --

Ladysmom

View Latest Entries